Newsletter (16th May'08 - 31st May'08)
(6/1/2008)

 



Fortnightly Newsletter

(16th May
`08 - 31st May`08)

 

www.studying-islam.org

Compiled by: Azeem Ayub

 

Reflections

 

In the Name of Allah,
the Most Gracious,
the Ever Merciful

 

 

The Political System of Pakistan: Points to Ponder

 

In compliance with the Qur’ānic injunction ‘أَمْرُهُمْ شُورَى بَيْنَهُمْ’ (their system is based on their consultation), the Sunnah decreed by the Prophet (sws) is based on two principles: First, Muslims shall be consulted in the affairs of state through their leaders in whom they profess confidence. Second, among the various parties or groups present in an Islamic State, only that party shall assume its political authority which enjoys the confidence of the majority.
 

It is evident from the above two principles that the real essence of democracy definitely exists in an Islamic Political System, however, there are certain evils present in the prevailing system of democracy of Pakistan, which are contrary to the teachings of Islam. Some of the important ones are listed below.
 

The first evil is that greed for an office in government has become so desirable a trait that even the pious feel no aversion to it. It has now become a tradition for people to come forward and present their names for various posts, go about proclaiming their qualities and services in streets and employ other means to allure the public. In Islamic ethics, this shameless attitude is not permissible at all. The Prophet (sws) is said to have said:
 

إِنَّا وَاللَّهِ لَا نُوَلِّي عَلَى هَذَا الْعَمَلِ أَحَدًا سَأَلَهُ وَلَا أَحَدًا حَرَصَ عَلَيْهِ (مسلم: رقم ١٧٣٣)

By God! We shall not grant any person a post in this system who asks for it and covets it. (Muslim: No. 1733)
 

The second evil is that people are generally encouraged to vote for whatever is in the party’s interest, even if their conscience considers it against the truth. Quite evidently, this attitude cannot be tolerated by the adherents of a religion whose followers have pledged a covenant at the hands of the Prophet (sws) that they would always say what is right disregarding ‘the reproaches of a one who reproaches’.

 

The third evil is that money has become the decisive factor in this system’s election campaigns. Therefore, only people who are able to spend lavishly in these campaigns, however little they might know about politics, however much they may lack in wisdom and intellect and however low they may be in character, reach parliament. Islam on the contrary, as every one knows, stresses that only people who are pious and noble, worthy and competent should assume political authority. It totally disapproves that money should rule the realm of politics in place of intellect and morality.

These are some of the evils which plague the democratic order of Pakistan whenever it is allowed to flourish. In their presence, it cannot be expected to function in accordance with the guidance provided by Islam. The whole set-up must be reformed and rehabilitated to harmonize it with the spirit of Islam’s political directives.

 

(Adapted from Ghamidi’s ‘Burhān’)

 

 

Author: Shehzad Saleem

 

Topic URL: http://www.monthly-renaissance.com/issue/content.aspx?id=467

 

In this Issue

Reflections
* The Political System
    of Pakistan: Points to
    Ponder
 

Read & Reflect
* The Phases &
    Abodes of the day
    of  Judgement

 

 Debate & Discuss
Discussion Forum:
    Understanding
    Islamic Political
    Directives
 

 return to the top ^

Express & Explain
* General Discussion
    Forum: Arguments
    regarding the
    Existence of God
  

 return to the top ^ 
 

Pause & Ponder
* 
 Origin of Prophetic
    Teachings
 

Announcements

 

Successful
    Participants

 

Recent Additions
*  Articles
  
*  Q n As
 
   

   return to the top ^

  

Spot on Site

 

 

 

 return to the top ^

   return to the top ^

 

Read and Reflect

 

The Phases and Abodes of the Day of Judgement

 

Author

Javed Ahmad Ghamidi

(Tr. by Shehzad Saleem)

 

The phases through which a person passes and the abodes in which he is lodged during his journey to meet his Lord are also mentioned in the Qur’ān. Slowly but surely, he is moving to encounter his Lord. The first phase of this journey is death. After a short stay in this world, every single person passes through this phase. There is no escape from it. The Almighty has said: كُلُّ نَفْسٍ ذَائِقَةُ المَوْت (٣: ١٨٥) (Every person shall taste death, (3:185)). It can come in the morning and it can come in the evening; one may taste it even before one’s birth or right after birth. It can come in childhood, in youth or in old age at any time and every person has to submit to it whether he likes it or not. According to the Qur’ān, at death, the real personality of a person which is called the soul by the Qur’ān and which is independent of his body is separated from his mortal being. The Almighty has told us that initially also it was given to man at the culmination of his mortal being which took place after passing through various phases and today also it is given to it once about 120 days elapse on the embryo.1 Death is the name of separating this personality of a person from his body. A specific angel – who has a whole staff of angels – is deputed for this task.2 He formally comes and collects a person’s soul just as a government official entrusted for collecting something discharges his responsibility:

 

قُلْ يَتَوَفَّاكُم مَّلَكُ الْمَوْتِ الَّذِي وُكِّلَ بِكُمْ ثُمَّ إِلَى رَبِّكُمْ تُرْجَعُونَ (١١:٣٢)

Tell them: “The angel of death deputed over you shall claim your souls. Then to your Lord shall you be returned.” (32:11)

 

At this instance, what happens to a person is also depicted in the Qur’ān. The souls of people who have deliberately rejected their prophets even after being convinced of their veracity are claimed by the angels whilst they hit and strike these disbelievers and at this very juncture of death they inform them that a terrible torment awaits them because of their evil deeds:

 

وَلَوْ تَرَى إِذْ يَتَوَفَّى الَّذِينَ كَفَرُواْ الْمَلآئِكَةُ يَضْرِبُونَ وُجُوهَهُمْ وَأَدْبَارَهُمْ وَذُوقُواْ عَذَابَ الْحَرِيقِ ذَلِكَ بِمَا قَدَّمَتْ أَيْدِيكُمْ وَأَنَّ اللّهَ لَيْسَ بِظَلاَّمٍ لِّلْعَبِيدِ (٨: ٥٠-٥١)

And if you could see the angels when they take away the souls of these disbelievers whilst striking them on their faces and their backs and [say:] “Taste now the torment of the fire! This is the punishment for the deeds you committed with your own hands and [you should know that] God does not do the slightest of injustice to His servants.” (8:50-51)


 

Read URL: http://www.monthly-renaissance.com/issue/content.aspx?id=719


 

__________________
1.
The Qur’ān, 32:6-9; 23:12-14; Tirmidhī, No: 2137.
 

Debate and Discuss:

 
 

 

Discussion Forum: Understanding Islamic Political Directives  

Topic: Module 4: Democracy and Islam

Siddiq Bukhary(Moderator)
Why do you think it is necessary not to accept a hadith unless it meets the criteria ascertained by the scholars of the science of the hadith? Does a Hadith become absolute truth after it is rendered acceptable by the scholars of the science of Hadith?

perv1
None

saqi12345
Is it a comparison between contemporary western democracy and Islamic political system as outlined in the Quran and the Sunnah duly followed by four caliphs of Islam?

askhalifa
1. In Islamic political system, law making authority cannot cross the boundary of Quran and sunnah, where as there is no such restriction in democracy in general.

2. In Islamic political system choice of a ruler is based on consensus of either intellectuals or masses, where as in current democratic system choice of ruler is based on selection of majority.

perv1
1. Democracies are governed in general by constitution. In an Islamic system the Quran would form the constitution. If however the majority decided to have laws contrary to the Quran. Then it cannot be considered to be an Islamic state. Ultimately the majority have to decide whether they wish to live within Islamic bounds or not. As there is no compulsion in religion no one should force their will on the majority.

2.'In Islamic political system choice of a ruler is based on consensus of either intellectuals or masses, where as in current democratic system choice of ruler is based on selection of majority'

Democracy is based on consensus of the masses.

Who exactly are the intellectuals.

saqi12345
1. the views expressed by perv1 at point 1 is the correct stand on the issue.

2. the question raised by perv1 at point 2 is logical.

as per Islamic teachings, the principal "the system is based on consultation" has no discrimination of intellectuals and otherwise. matter of public interest will be decided by "the majority opinion of the masses" is the common point between Islam and democracy. however , the difference between the two systems is sufficiently covered at point 1 by perv1.

Siddiq Bukhary (Moderator)
Saqi has correctly summarised the subject . I hope, now there is no ambiguity in this matter.

 

Express and Explain:

 

  General Discussion Forum:

Arguments regarding the Existence of God

 

 

aijaz47

Dear Mr. Hanif

 

Existence does not necessarily have to be physical. As regards Mermaids, their existence is imaginary or fictional. Thus if it has a name it exists.

 

Secondly, denial does not mean that that particular thing does not exist. One shall have to provide the prove for the denial. Physical existence is an attribute. So far it seems Mermaids do not have that attribute. Their existence is fictional. Can you deny the fictional existence of Mermaids?

 

Thirdly, Allah is The Creator of Universe and Claims to be so. I have not heard of anyone claiming to be the creator of The Creator. Answer shall be provided when the question arises.

 

student1

This is your reply to Mr. Hanif but I would like to present my comments on your reply and I hope you wont mind.

 

quote:

 

Dear Mr. Hanif
 
You Said:
Existence does not necessarily have to be physical. As regards Mermaids, their existence is imaginary or fictional. Thus if it has a name it exists.

Comment:
I agree with you on that, existence doesn’t necessarily has to be physical since their are many non-physical elements which have existence but they are invisible for us.
As far as Mermaids are concerned, no doubt they are considered to be fictional and imaginary but if it has a particular name, it doesn’t necessarily mean that they exists, take an example of Aliens, they have a name but so far their existence is just a hypothesis and their are no explicit evidence which could really prove their existence.

You Said:
Secondly, denial does not mean that that particular thing does not exist. One shall have to provide the prove for the denial. Physical existence is an attribute. So far it seems Mermaids do not have that attribute. Their existence is fictional. Can you deny the fictional existence of Mermaids?

Comment:
I agree with you, denial doesn’t mean that a particular thing does not exist but if it does exists then their has to be some explicit evidences which should prove its existence.

You said:
Thirdly, Allah is The Creator of Universe and Claims to be so. I have not heard of anyone claiming to be the creator of The Creator. Answer shall be provided when the question arises.

Comments:
According to my limited knowledge, we have not heard anyone claiming to be a Creator of the Creator but history tells us that during the period of Pharaoh, People of Egypt use to worship him since he use to claim that he was(Naoozubilah) God and he gives life and death to people but he never provided any strong evidences to prove himself as God but still people use to blindly worship him because they feared his power of kingdom.

 
Their were several people who claimed to be Gods but how would you convince an atheist that their is no God but Allah(swt)?

 

aijaz47

So you agree that denial does not mean that a particular thing does not exist. Thanks for accepting my point.

Allah is The Creator of the universe.

In the known history I have not been able to find anyone other that Allah who claimed to be the creator of the universe. If you know someone kindly introduce it to me.

People have been worshiping many imaginary gods since the beginning of the time but have you ever heard any of them making any such claim.

 

aijaz47
Main Entry: alien
Function: noun
Date: 14th century

1 : a person of another family, race, or nation
2 : a foreign-born resident who has not been naturalized and is still a subject or citizen of a foreign country; broadly : a foreign-born citizen
3 : extraterrestrial

Main Entry: alien
Pronunciation: ‚†-l‡-„n, ‚†l-y„n
Function: adjective
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin alienus, from alius
Date: 14th century


1 a : belonging or relating to another person, place, or thing : strange b : relating, belonging, or owing allegiance to another country or government : foreign
2 : differing in nature or character typically to the point of incompatibility
synonyms see extrinsic
–alien£ly adverb
–alien£ness \-l‡-„n-n„s, -y„n-n„s\ noun

Main Entry: alien
Function: transitive verb
Date: 14th century

1 : alienate, estrange
2 : to make over (as property)

Above are the meaning of the word Alien from the Merriam-Webster Collegiate dictonary.

 

aijaz47

This is in reply to your question "who created Allah?"

My answer is that if it is created then it is not Allah.

Allah is the Supreme Creator.


jxmedina
I must say that I have not read through the other area where this topic was discussed, but I wanted to make just a couple of comments. Denial does not take away existence, and for me, atheists that I have known in college, affirm Allah's exists in their very denial. Because if something is nonexistence then there is no reason to deny it. One can only deny something, but cannot deny nothing. This is my opinion.

Also, I agree there are things that exist that are physical and intangible. Does courage not exist because we cannot see it or touch it? Does fear not exist although we cannot see it or touch it? How about love? How about thinking? Thoughts and memories are intangible, but we all know they exist. But again, it does depend on what type of existence is under investigation. We see the power and creations of Almighty Allah in everything and everyplace, and everyone. Allah created all things whether we choose to believe or not, it takes nothing away from the fact that He exists. May Allah guide us all.

 

aijaz47

Kindly go to Forums> History of Quran> Collection under Abu Bakar ( may Allah be pleased with him).

 

Jhangeer Hanif (modeator)


You write:

Existence does not necessarily have to be physical.

Comments:

I think you want to say that existence does not have to be 'actual'. Because we know that mermaids do not actually exist; they are fictitious in contrast to reality. We are not taking about the nature of God's existence - spirirtual or physical; we are talking about whether it is actual or not. Hence when we talk about mermaids, we know that their existence is not actual or real. Is this the case with God?

You write:

Secondly, denial does not mean that that particular thing does not exist. One shall have to provide the prove for the denial. Physical existence is an attribute. So far it seems Mermaids do not have that attribute. Their existence is fictional. Can you deny the fictional existence of Mermaids?

Comments:

In the second response, you are again confusing 'actual or real' with 'physical'. I am not talking about the nature of existence. I am talking about whether something really exists? Hence the stress is on real. I had written

About second argument, If someone denies the existence of mermaids, they are right in doing so. This does not prove the existence of mermaids - which no one has ever been foolish enough to profess. Does it?
I meant to say that their existence is not actual. So if someone denies that mermaid in reality does not exist, they would be right in doing so.

You write:

Thirdly, Allah is The Creator of Universe and Claims to be so. I have not heard of anyone claiming to be the creator of The Creator. Answer shall be provided when the question arises.
 

Comments:
About the third argument, the atheist would simply say that I do not see him make such a claim. Because, if he were to see God as making a claim, he would not question his existence since it would have been empirical for him.

 

 

 

Pause and Ponder:

 

 

Status of Dictatorship in Islam

Question asked by B. A. Malik.
Posted on: Tuesday, January 02, 2006 - Hits: 616

 

Question

Please tell me what is the stand of Islam on military rule. Is army rule in Pakistan Islamic or unislamic?

 

Answer:
 

Dictatorship of any kind is not allowed in Islam. Islam requires from the believers that their political affairs be run on the basis of consultation between the masses. Only that person is eligible to rule who commands the confidence of the majority. You may also refer to the following articles regarding the basic Islamic teachings in this regard:

 

Democracy and Islam and The State System .

 

Regards,

 

 

Tariq Mahmood Hashmi

Research Assistant, Studying Islam




See:
http://www.studying-islam.org/querytext.aspx?id=692

return to the top ^

 

 

Announcements:

 

Faith Anchor
 

Faith Anchor


As we have mentioned about this project in our Interfaith Forums, the 1st event of this series took place recently in the Royal County of UK.  We tend to take it further and organize more events under this banner-not limiting to UK, rather extending it to the other countries of Europe and other Continents.

We welcome any suggestions and ideas in this regard.
Send to

faithanchors@aol.com or
admin@studying-islam.org

 

Successful Participants
 

ID

Course Name

Country

Grade

6282 Arrangement of the Qur'an Pakistan C+
8742 Family and Marriage: Core Issues Pakistan D
8742 Family and Marriage: Related Issues Pakistan B
4834 History of the Qur'an Nigeria C+
8910 Introduction to the Hadith USA A+
5425 Norms of Gender Interaction Pakistan E+
8888 The Religion of Islam UK C+
8742

Ta'ruf i Hadith

Pakistan C+

 

 return to the top ^ 

Recent Additions:

 

Articles

Positive Contribution of Islamic Social Values to the West.

Alice in Wonderland! Who are You?

And Two become One

you can have free sex now because you are 16!!

Before you tie the knot

 

  •  

    QnA
     

    An Objection to Women Heading a State

    Cousin Marriages

    Keeping Dogs as Pets

    The Diyat of Women

    Women can't become Heads of State

  •  
     

     return to the top ^

  •  

     

     

    Spot on Site:

     

    Dialogue with the Islamic World

    http://www.qantara.de

     

     

     return to the top ^

     

     

     

    Please give us your valued feedback on our guestbook:
     http://www.studying-islam.org/guestbook.aspx

     

     

    ______________________

     

    Studying Islam
    51-K Model Town Lahore 54700 Pakistan
    Ph: 92-42-586 5145, 92-42-583 4306 Fax: 92-42-586 4856

    URL: www.studying-islam.org

    Email: info@studying-islam.org