| Author | Topic |
abunoman
PAKISTAN
|
 Topic initiated on Wednesday, February 24, 2010 - 8:23 AM 
Hadith Al-da'if - 4 (Zaeef hadith)
Hadith al-Da’if – 4 (Zaeef hadees)
“Seek knowledge even if you have to go to China”.
Allama Ibn Jawzee in ‘al-Mawzoo’at’ described this hadith a fabrication.
According to Allama al-Bayhaqee, this hadith has a famous content but a weak chain of narrations.
Ibn Hibban, Ibn al-Sakhawi declared this as a ‘maudu’ hadith. Allama Dhahbi in ‘ Tarteeb-al-Mawzoo’at’ commented this hadith to be ‘maudu’ and that has no basis.
Shaikh Nasir uddin Albanee mentioned this hadith to be false (fabricated).
Being this hadith to be ‘mashoor’ (famous) some scholars have classified this hadith as ‘hasan’.
However the following hadith is ‘saheeh’ (correct) :
“Seeking knowledge is an obligation for every muslim (men & women)”.
This hadith exists in different versions with some additions which were discarded being weak or fabricated by Allama Albanee.
|
|
aboosait
INDIA
|
Posted - Tuesday, March 2, 2010 - 3:17 PM 
quote:
Hadith al-Da’if – 4 (Zaeef hadees)
“Seek knowledge even if you have to go to China”.
Allama Ibn Jawzee in ‘al-Mawzoo’at’ described this hadith a fabrication.
According to Allama al-Bayhaqee, this hadith has a famous content but a weak chain of narrations.
Ibn Hibban, Ibn al-Sakhawi declared this as a ‘maudu’ hadith. Allama Dhahbi in ‘ Tarteeb-al-Mawzoo’at’ commented this hadith to be ‘maudu’ and that has no basis.
Shaikh Nasir uddin Albanee mentioned this hadith to be false (fabricated).
Being this hadith to be ‘mashoor’ (famous) some scholars have classified this hadith as ‘hasan’.
However the following hadith is ‘saheeh’ (correct) :
“Seeking knowledge is an obligation for every muslim (men & women)”.
This hadith exists in different versions with some additions which were discarded being weak or fabricated by Allama Albanee.
There are numerous unfounded narrations in circulation today that are Da’eef, Munkar, Baatil, Mawdoo or Baseless ahaadeeth. As such, it is our obligation to discuss them and indicate their erroneousness. Jazakallahu khair.
Please click on the following URL and follow the links to know more:
http://www.allaahuakbar.in/ahaadeeth/weak_fabricated_&;_baatil_ahaadeeth.htm |
|
abunoman
PAKISTAN
|
Posted - Thursday, March 4, 2010 - 6:40 AM
Thank you Mr Aboosait for the URL you posted.
With highest regards. |
|
 Reply to Topic 
Printer Friendly |
| Jump To: |
|
|
|