Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salam Alekum

Being explicit, I agree to what Imran776 writes.

Waseem Pls. investigate the word Darab scholastically and you would find this word is neither symbolic nor is Context-specific. The word Darab (is even not a term) is very much general and means Beating, in here (4:34).

2nd thing if you really want to help yourself reach a conclusion then first just get rid of intentions to bring about a West-acclimatized Version of Islam. In Quran, there are certain things that do change its shade as per the situation that evolves, but certainly 4:34 is not among those. Allah (s.w.t.) made Men and Women and he (s.w.t.) knows well how to deal with all. We may not know or see the true results of this act (beating) but ought to accept that it’s a reality and very much approved by Quran.

38:44 is also supports that Islam does allow (of course not mandatory or even encouraging) Husbands beating Wives. But surely as a last resort to avoid disintegration of a family (Talaq).

You have ignored my pleas so far that 4:34 is not superimposing over the State’s regulations about family matters and if a certain country debars Men from Beating Wives then one must obey the State’s regulations and should opt for some other alternative to save the institution of his family. In other countries, where its not a punishable crime, such an act would stand deplorable but certainly would not be punishable or would not be regarded as a Sin as per Islam.

Resp. Moderator, yes I translated “Katehra” as I believe that those who have least acquaintance with your Urdu also click this Link. And, with due respect, I wish someone could translate the Word “Moderator” for you (Pls. draw a Smiley face here, I’m not good at it). I guess, I’ll soon see my fate of throwing out of the forum, ..well perhaps.

Ma’salam

Kashan Iqbal
Dubai[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview