Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]AOA Mujahid

[quote] Please,rest assured that i am not a blind follower of any scholar present or past [/quote]

Nice to hear this but I made no comment on you following any scholar

[quote] I have understood religion putting in a lot of sincere efforts in it as a very ordinary muslim.I am only writing the conclusions of how i have understood the basics. [/quote]

Thats fine my friend as each one of us has to reach his/her own conclusions.

[quote] I am still very open minded and prepared to submit to the truth whereever and whenever it is presented to me [/quote]

nice to hear.

[quote] partly agree with your opinion.Ahadith cannot be considered as an original source of islam.The inherent weaknesses in it are very obvious. [/quote]
Hopefully one day you will fully agree with me.

[quote] It is the unshakable Quran&the Established sunnah of the prophet pbuh which forms the integral part of Islam, the transmission of which is something the world has never experienced before [/quote]
I also partly agree with you about the Quran bit but the Sunnah bit has no basis from the Quran or makes any logical or intellectual sense but then each one of us to satisfy our own logic and intellect just as the Quran tells us to.

[quote] Having said that when seen under the light of Quran and sunnah there is a lot of guidance one can derive from Ahadith. [/quote]
If you wish to take your guidance from hadith then that is your progative.

[quote] Just because of some narrator's unintentional or intentional interpolation of the text the whole discipline cannot be considered as fruitless. [/quote]
We are not discussing some manual or literature that we can ignore the rubbish and concentrate on the good bits only. The hadith have become an integral part of Islam and the only goodness they have brought is to the enemies of islam by portraying it as an evil. illogical and contradictory religion ( if you wish i can provide you with countless examples). Accepting some hadith and rejecting others is bit like saying I believe in part of but not all of God.

[quote] As an ordinary muslim i have spent hours and hours to understand the issue and Alhamdolill'Allah i can now say that i have managed to get to the bottom of it only through the approach being promoted by this website. [/quote]

I am glad for you.

[quote] Javaid Ahmad Ghamidhi's services in separating sunnah from hadith are unprecedented and quite remarkable. [/quote]

I am afraid i dont share your high opinion of him. I find his work contradictory and intellectually very weak.

Regards[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview